I was skeptical at first, but this works pretty well and the case is attractive. I have dropped my phone in the case (my fault), which left a little mar in the case, but the case protected the phone like it was supposed to. Holster works pretty well, but it is difficult to remove from your belt (which is both good and bad depending on the situation). I have high seat bolsters in my car, so the holster hits my seat when I get in it and I broke the holster. You can't order just the holster to replace it. All in all, it still worked pretty well, so I got another kit to replace the one I broke. Now I remove it before I get in my car, and sometimes just clip it to my pants pocket.